You are here: Home / Tested / Same engine and DSG transmission. So it’s a two-door Golf R in a frock, right? Wrong



Latest topCar Blogs

Reader Blogs

Newsletter

Subscribe
Unsubscribe

Same engine and DSG transmission. So it’s a two-door Golf R in a frock, right? Wrong

By: 
Ashley Oldfield

Tue, 2011/09/27 - 3:11pm — asholdfield

Same engine and DSG transmission. So it’s a two-door Golf R in a frock, right? Wrong
By: 
Ashley Oldfield

SEEMS YOU’RE SPOILT for choice if you’re a fan of hot hatches and the VW badge. The new Scirocco R finishes off a quartet of VW sports cars that includes the ubiquitous Golf GTI and the recently launched Polo GTI and Golf R. Like the Golf R, the heart of the Scirocco is the same 2.0-litre, four-cylinder turbocharged engine found in the Audi S3, and not the newer EA888 engine fitted to the Golf GTI and the conventional Scirocco. More about that later, but comparisons between the Golf R and the Scirocco are inevitable given that they’re mechanically related and specced similarly. They are quite different though.

Exterior

Ever heard of Beatrix Kiddo? The katana wielding bridal assassin? Yup, that would be Uma Thurman in Kill Bill. Beautiful to behold, ever so slightly mental and definitely not to be messed with. The Scirocco has a bit of Uma in it, and that’s a good thing. It’s lower, wider and sexier than the tubbier Golfs, and the R has several subtle bespoke tweaks that differentiate it from lesser Sciroccos. These include revised bumpers front and rear, larger 19-inch five-spoke alloys, LED daytime running lights, two chromed exhaust exits set in a diffuser, a larger rear wing, gloss black detailing on the grille and mirrors, smoked rear light lenses and new side sills. Call it understated aggression, just like Uma in a spandex suit ready for some slice-and-dice.

Interior

Inside it’s a more sombre story, although VW has tried to liven things up with R logos, blue dials, gloss black and aluminium inserts, and the GTI’s familiar flat-bottomed steering wheel. Our test unit came specced with an optional panoramic sunroof (R8 820) and racing bucket seats (R20 000). We’d lose the sunroof and ditch the buckets for the more practical but still supportive standard sports seats that make getting in and out of the car a lot easier. The usual Scirocco niggles remain. There’s no release on the hatch itself, which means you have to open it either with a button on the key or flip the release switch in the car itself. Visibility to the rear is compromised by the sloping roof and small rear window, but at least park distance control comes standard. Plus there’s not a lot of headroom in the back if you’re intent on cramming two adults behind the front seats.

Performance

There’s no whining if you’re the one behind the wheel though. We mentioned earlier that the R uses the older Audi S3 engine, a proven mill fettled to 188kW and 350Nm of torque. Our test unit featured a six-speed manual transmission (R403 355), not the more expensive dual-clutch transmission (which pushes the sticker price to R417 855) and for once we didn’t miss the DSG box. There’s a strong surge to the engine with a nice burble to the exhaust note as you accelerate and shift through the gears. It’s pretty quick too, with our 0-100kph time at Killarney Race Track coming up in
6.45 seconds. Claimed time for the DSG version is 5.8 seconds.

Handling

Your rating: None Average: 4.2 (5 votes)

Comments

Anonymous's picture

i love the idea of that car

i love the idea of that car and it is really nice. the design is nice and elegant. however vw emblem on the front ruins the hood it should be smaller and tucked in to the grille. i guess they are doint some car recall with it.

Paul JA Broers's picture

Beatrix Kiddo?

Beatrix Kiddo? Or could the Scirocco not be Cinderella with an attitude? Pitted against her own stable ugly sisters. Who would chose a dumpy ( but still timelessly pleasant enough) Golf R when they could stretch to this one, albeit for a premium. Polarised buyers, that's who, and they would be unlikely to compare one with the other, equal heartbeats notwithstanding. And that's because the Scirocco is not a hatchback in the undiluted definition of the word. It's a coupe that happens to have a hatch, and adults squeeze into the back at their own peril. Personally I'm always bewildered that track compatabilty/performance is a comparitive test criterea. Track stuff is for the Lotus Elize which looks as daft on public roads as the Scirocco would look trying to blow it off on the track. But that's just me.   

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.

Featured Video

Polls

What's your opinion on the number of doors your car should have?: