You are here: Home / Comparisons / Citroen DS3 vs Alfa Mito vs Mini Cooper S



Latest topCar Blogs

Reader Blogs

Newsletter

Subscribe
Unsubscribe

Citroen DS3 vs Alfa Mito vs Mini Cooper S

By: 
Calvin Fisher

Tue, 2010/08/24 - 9:36am — ashtest

Citroen DS3 vs Alfa Mito vs Mini Cooper S
By: 
Calvin Fisher

THE HOT CHOCOLATE gulped down at the Engen 1-Stop is now just a distant memory as the bitter cold creeps into the cabin of the Mini Cooper S. Ahead of me loom the N1 tollgate’s booms, and beyond that the Huguenot Tunnel. I’m playing chase with the Mini’s fiercest foes yet: Alfa’s Mito Quadrifoglio and Citroën’s new DS3 THP, each scything their way through traffic. None in this trio is a middling hatch; each oozes an indisputable Euro cool, each qualifies to be the premium darling in the junior academy. But we’re going to get even cooler to find a victor.

IMAGE GALLERY

‘Looks like it’s going to rain,’ mouths snapper Peet from the seat next to me. I more or less make out what he’s saying despite the fact that we’re being rudely buffeted by icy winter wind thanks to an open sunroof. He’ll be standing up through that just now. Grey and drizzly, the weather is quickly dampening our mood. Then total darkness, quickly followed by yellow light as the cars are bathed in the overhead lamps of the 3.9km-long tunnel. None of us are above man’s natural instinct to hoof it in these acoustically enhanced surroundings. ‘Whoop! Tss! Baark!’ Aah! It’s music to our ears as three turboed four-pots conduct a crackling, hissing mechanical symphony in the Huguenot’s chambers. Even with a 90kph speed limit, the road offers up some entertaining jinks as we traverse its 22-year-old surface bumper to bumper. Fun, sure, but nothing prepares us for the scene as we explode into the light once more. SNOW! Light, fluffy and everywhere. White dusted mountain ranges flanking the highway, surreal to our summer mindsets, are a signal to bring our tiny convoy to a halt.

HEY GOOD LOOKING

Stopping firmly comes naturally to these performers, but it’s not an easy thing to do when they offer up such thrills on the move. It’s a chance though to take in the visual treats these sporting European fashion accessories have to offer. They’re all cast in a deliciously different mould: the Mini a throwback pastiche of the 1950s icon, the Mito a slippery Italian blend of muscle and stance, the DS3 a futuristic concoction that does an un-retro about face, yet still parallels the Mini’s formula. They even share an engine.

The DS3 is resplendent in yellow, with a blackened zebra-themed roof, attention-grabbing white 17inch alloy hoops, and bold chrome blade along its flanks. It fights hard for attention, with the shark-fin C-pillar treatment stealing the show and leaving no doubt that Citroën has regained its design mojo. Our test unit is perhaps not specced in the best colour combination from the extensive Citroën palette, but the result is striking and immediately ages the ‘familiar’ Mini.

The Alfa too gives the Mini a drubbing in terms of fresh aesthetics. Despite the cutesy surprised expression on its face, it’s the more macho car here, due in large part to those severely pumped arches housing anthracite alloy wheels. The anthracite treatment extends

Your rating: None Average: 3.7 (6 votes)

Comments

Aubrey Kloppers's picture

Alfa makes me think of "My Name is Earle"

As Earle's friend said when he shuved the kazoo into his backside and Earle unknowingly blew on it: "Pucker-Up, stinky-lips".

 

This is what the alfa looks like.  AND I think they followed suit on the old Jaguars <hahaha> - pucker-up stinkey-lips!!!

Anonymous's picture

Engines...

Stop complaining...


They comparing two 1.6 litre engines (Mini and DS3) to Alfa Romeo's 1.4... So even if they use Mini's new engine with 135kw its still a 1.6 litre vs Alfa's little 1.4.


So imagine the performance if Alfa put a 1.6 unit in the Mito... Will make the DS3 and "new" Mini look like ox wagons. Based on Alfa's 125Kw on 1.4 a 1.6 Alfa Engine will kick out 142kw... A lot more than Mini's 135kw

Style_Wars's picture

"They comparing two 1.6 litre

"They comparing two 1.6 litre engines (Mini and DS3) to Alfa Romeo's 1.4... So even if they use Mini's new engine with 135kw its still a 1.6 litre vs Alfa's little 1.4."

 

Alfa don't have a 1.6 engine, it's a 1.7 MultiAir ...Alfa decided against using it for the MiTo ... the Prince Engine on the Mini/DS3 has a 1.4 Variant...which is not Turbocharged... they decided on using the 1.6 for the application ...to think Alfa would have made a 1.6 witha much more power to the Mini/DS3 is debatable...you need to remember even the 125 kW on the MiTo is a "tune-up" it's turbocharged afterall ...the Prince in application comes in a NA and churns out 88kW, then the Turbo starts from 110kW, 135kW and 155 kW ...again it doesn't seem fair to compare the DS3 110kW version to the 135kW version on the Mini??? I agree that they really cannot compare these cars on names and engines in different categories.... the Prince on the DS3 can actually be bumped up to 168 kW and that's from PSA Peugot-Citroen ...the DS3 will also get a 155kW variant soon ... it's a mismatched comparison really ...engines are different classes/categories ...even with the DS3/Mini as welll it's still debatable... they are not tuned to same specs ...

Ryan's picture

Re engines

Firstly, i do prefer the Alfa of this bunch, best car here and cloverleaf is much improved. The kW output of these 3 cars is very similar so the engines can be compared. As for the 142kW Alfa motor, remember the Mini engine is also cranked up to 155kW for the JCW, still a 1.6. Both these engines though have won engine of the year awards so i still think it's apples with apples

Anonymous's picture

Re: Engines

Yes the JCW kicks out 155kw but that is a tuned up engine. This estimated 142kw is straight from Alfa's production line (should they ever produce a 1.6 MultiAir engine).

What will happen to that estimated 142kw if Autodelta (who is Alfa's equivilant of JCW) gets a hold of that motor?

Owned many Alfa's in my life so my view towards them might be a little biased seeing that I am a true Alfisti... Already ordered my Giulietta, just waiting for it to arrive in SA.

Anonymous's picture

Mini 2010?

Just a note clever reviewer...

Seeing that the DS3 and Mito are new cars and have new engines, why not take the updated 2010 Mini Cooper S with 135kw bmw technology engine???

They keep on comparing these new cars to the older Mini..although they still get whipped...i'd just like to see how far the others get behind then. fyi, the new engines have been out for 3 months already.

Its not an accurate measurement..give buyers better information

use it dont use it.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Featured Video

Polls

What hatchback is the best buy right now?: